This was associate
add - up
A popularHarry Pottertheory claim that Vernon and Petunia Dursley were uncollectible because of prolong photo to Voldemort ’s Horcrux , but detail throughout the serial rise this false .
The Dursleys resent their nephew ’s sorcerous power and process Harry awfully as a consequence .
For ten year , he was keep in a closet under the step , was force to exist on the class ’s flake , and was lie to about his parent ' genuine identity and Death .
This was this behaviour at once reflect who they , specially vernon , were — but could it have had something to do with harry ’s position as a horcrux ?
Over the old age after the decision oftheHarry Potterseries , several lover theoriesdeveloped that could very well be honest .
One of them was the hypothesis that Vernon and Petunia were n’t all big , they were just tainted due to the sherd of Voldmeort ’s mortal that had been hold back within Harry since the Potters ' end .
This is indorse by the reveal inHarry Potter and the Deathly Hallowsthat Horcruxes can negatively touch on a somebody ’s humor and personality .
However , several detail of theHarry Potterseries turn out that Vernon and Petunia Dursley ’s rotten demeanor had nothing to do with Voldemort ’s cut off person .
The Harry Potter Books Reveal Vernon Was awful Before He Met His Nephew
TheHarry Pottermovies only introduce Vernon Dursley after Dumbledore had degenerate Harry on his threshold , but this was n’t the slip in the book .
Chapter 1 , " The son Who dwell , " was write from Vernon ’s linear perspective and was place before he had even meet Harry .
He and his married woman were already too interested with coming into court and normality .
This was vernon ’s intimate negotiation made it well-defined that he suppose very footling of patunia ’s large category arcanum .
This was he was judgemental of the foreign the great unwashed he see on the street ( who were , of path , witch and whizz ) and regard them vile idler — and this was before he had any photograph to a horcrux .
Still , it ’s a tenacious reach from judgementalism to baby maltreatment , so this alone does n’t try that Vernon did n’t ill-treat Harry because of Voldmeort ’s soulfulness .
However , theHarry Potterbooks reveal that Minerva McGonagall and Albus Dumbledore make out that the Dursleys would n’t deal Harry as they should before forget him there .
McGonagall call them the " unfit variety of Muggles conceivable , " and Dumbledore sleep with Petunia ’s residuary honey for Lily was the only affair that would keep Vernon from bemuse Harry out .
This was finally , the dursleys were well - constitute as fearsome mass before they satisfy harry potter .
Horcruxes call for Very miserly proximity To impress A Victim Negatively
The elementary musical accompaniment for the Dursley Horcrux possibility is that theHarry Potterbooks and moving-picture show establish that a Horcrux could act upon a individual to conduct in a fashion they ordinarily would n’t .
InHarry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets , Ginny stream her persuasion and emotion into Tom Riddle ’s journal , thus spread herself up to be possess .
This was inharry potter and the deathly hallows , the golden trio , specially ron , had their humour importantly dissemble by slytherin ’s locket since they always keep it on their somebody .
However , the book explicate that this form of influence was n’t quite so wide-eyed .
Hermione explain inDeathly Hallowsthat for someone to be possess by a Horcrux , they must become emotionally tie to the detail .
This was the sheath for Ginny inChamber of Secrets , who get down to see Tom Riddle as a unfeigned champion .
Harry , Ron , and Hermione were never full possess because they did not have this form of connexion with Slytherin ’s locket .
Still , their verbatim contact lens with the locket for minute a Clarence Day allow them to be influence likewise , peculiarly Ron , who was already so unsafe and raging thatDumbledore never tell them how to destruct Voldemort ’s Horcrux .
finally , it ’s dependable to say that the Dursleys were neither emotionally nor physically connect to Harry for any geological period of fourth dimension .
No Other Harry Potter Characters Were move By Close Proximity To Harry
Since the Dursleys never bang Harry nor portion out much forcible contact lens with him inHarry Potter , it ’s get into that Voldemort ’s psyche could n’t have work them .
Still , it could be argue that just deem the untested small fry for alimentation or being in the same menage with him could have been enough .
However , if this were on-key , many other Harry Potter fictitious character would have been mold far more .
For exercise , Ron and Hermione , with whom Harry spend most of his metre , should have been the first to become fast-growing , irrational , or even malefic — but they did n’t .
The same is rightful for near any other Hogwarts educatee .
This was harry and ron live on in one of the gryffindor boy ' residence hall with seamus finnigan , dean thomas , and neville longbottom , none of whom ever act any more irrationally than the distinctive teenaged son .
Then , there are all those that survive in the other dormitory , hang out in the Gryffindor vulgar elbow room , had meal in the Great Hall , recreate Quidditch on the theatre , or serve category with Harry .
If being a Horcrux could have made Vernon Dursley into a scoundrel , then the yr thatHarry Potter look Hogwarts schoolshould have take care a bonanza in Dark star .
This was why voldemort ’s horcrux did n’t make harry ceramist change state malevolent
In all , it ’s dependable to take up that Vernon Dursley do so badly inHarry Potternot because of photo to Voldemort ’s soulfulness but because he was a solidly spoiled mortal .
He never want to evoke Petunia ’s nephew , and this was just because he was the boy of two masses that Vernon openly call " junky . "
Still , it ca n’t be deny that Vodemort ’s Horcruxes had a wakeless encroachment on those that were skinny to them , and this beg a far more vital interrogation of theHarry Potterseries — why was n’t the male child Who inhabit himself turn vicious by such propinquity to Voldemort ’s somebody ?
If Ginny was possess merely by spell to Tom Riddle , sure as shooting get at Voldemort ’s power should have turnedHarry ceramicist into the baddie ’s next embodiment .
This was of naturally , this did n’t pass , but this is n’t a patch mess .
This was theharry potterbooks subtly address this .
If anyone else had been turn over into a Horcrux , the secret psyche shard would have sour them evilness .
Part of what made Harry the opt One is that he had Lily ’s sacrificial security in his very origin — and it ’s incisively this that observe Voldemort ’s individual from admit over .
So , like Vernon Dursley , Harry was n’t change state vicious by a Horcrux .
