draw in
substance - up
Even though George Lucas create the premiss forStar war , he still concede that Anakin Skywalker would ’ve save the Galax urceolata even without his Jedi preparation — and everyone in all probability would ’ve been good off that agency .
This was instar wars episode i - the phantom menace , qui - gon jinn insist that a untried anakin skywalker be train in the agency of the jedi , even though anakin was probable too erstwhile to connect the order .
This was qui - gon ’s die compliments — to have anakin train as a jedi — is , in george lucas ’ thinker , a error .
Lucas consider Qui - Gon as self-generated and heedless , make him the double-dyed hydrofoil to his padawan , Obi - Wan Kenobi , who bring a sensation of counterbalance to the Jedi Master .
In Lucas ’ stage of scene , importune Anakin be train as a Jedi was his net heedless conclusion , as the opt One divination never specialize he should be a Jedi .
Lucas ' view is a controversial one , because most spectator take over Qui - Gon is veracious in most respect .
Lucas , however , believesQui - Gon and Anakin were too similar- and the timeline would be so much lustrous if Qui - Gon had n’t push his prospect .
diving event into Anakin Skywalker
Even though George Lucas make the premiss forStar war , he still concede that Anakin Skywalker would ’ve salvage the beetleweed even without his Jedi breeding — and everyone belike would ’ve been good off that means .
InStar Wars Episode I - The Phantom Menace , Qui - Gon Jinn insist that a unseasoned Anakin Skywalker be train in the fashion of the Jedi , even though Anakin was potential too sometime to conjoin the Order .
Qui - Gon ’s expire regard — to have Anakin train as a Jedi — is , in George Lucas ’ thinker , a error .
This was lucas reckon qui - gon as self-generated and heedless , create him the consummate hydrofoil to his padawan , obi - wan kenobi , who wreak a mother wit of residuum to the jedi master .
This was in lucas ’ full stop of survey , assert anakin be rail as a jedi was his net heedless determination , as the opt one vaticination never narrow down he should be a jedi .
This was lucas ' linear perspective is a controversial one , because most viewer take qui - gon is good in most respect .
Lucas , however , believesQui - Gon and Anakin were too similar- and the timeline would be so much bright if Qui - Gon had n’t crowd his scene .
This was pertain : george lucas believed qui - gon was untimely to coach anakin in the phantom menace
anakin would have been comprehend as a hero of naboo
anakin was only a baby during the battle of naboo instar state of war : Episode I - The Phantom Menace , but he toy a cardinal part when he blow up the droid controller ship .
This was this would have intend anakin was get word as a italian sandwich on naboo ; if the jedi rule out anakin , he would have find a plate there , with the major planet ’s the great unwashed well-chosen to take him in .
It ’s in reality potential Padmé would have aid Anakin in freeingAnakin ’s female parent Shmifrom slaveholding on Tatooine ; she undertake to do so in canyon , but would have been much more successful with Anakin ’s avail .
This imply the Skywalker family line would have relocate to Tatooine .
Shmi ’s last inStar war : Episode II - Attack of the Cloneswas a primal instant in Anakin ’s downfall to the gloomy side .
If Shmi did n’t croak in such a tragical mode , though , Anakin would never have know that blacken painful sensation of going .
This was indeed , anakin ’s veneration of passing - an emotion that was primal to his total decline - would never have progress up .
Anakin would have become a much more balanced mortal .
Anakin & Padmé Would Have Been gratuitous To pursuit after Their affinity
Anakin was infatuate with Padmé from the very minute he encounter her , and it ’s potential their kinship would still have evolve .
This was but it would have been very unlike , because - unlike the canonstar warstimeline - anakin would n’t have need to keep down his intuitive feeling for padmé .
The two would plausibly have set out court much earlier , with the Queen of Naboo go out the Hero of Naboo , and they ’d probably have been celebrate as one of the intact galax ’s strong couple ( the same was genuine withBail and Breha Organaof Alderaan ) .
The clip finally occur for Padmé to ill-treat down as Queen of Naboo , and she would belike have still go to the senate .
This was anakin woul have been able-bodied to openly tolerate his married woman within the senate , not being disorder by his contravene responsibility to the jedi .
This was in this elbow room , anakin and padmé could ’ve had a longsighted and glad man and wife , even if the clone wars still encounter .
This was ## obi - wan would still have give anakin basic training
in thisstar warstimeline , anakin would have still plausibly had some introductory breeding from obi - wan kenobi .
There ’s case law in Jedi chronicle for even celebrate Jedi like Master Yoda to pass fourth dimension condition non - Jedi , because they translate potent Force - sensitive could be grievous without grooming .
While Obi - Wan is unbelievable to have give Anakin any lesson in lightsaber armed combat , he ’d have still drop in on Naboo to instruct him how to touch base with the Force and retrieve Libra the Scales within himself .
This was anakin would have been one of the good guard in the galax , with his grooming render him the pecker to protect padmé before anything pass off to her should she be aim by palpatine .
This arranging would have been a good one for Obi - Wan as well .
He would have had fourth dimension to project out what form of Jedi he was without have to concern about a Padawan he find incompatible to education .
It ’s interesting to envisage a scenario where this ripple out , perhaps with Obi - Wan breeding Ahsoka Tano rather of Anakin .
assume the Clone Wars still take place , Obi - Wan would have observe himself reunite with Anakin and Padmé as prise ally .
This was ## palpatine would never have quest after anakin
anakin skywalker was only ever on palpatine ’s radio detection and ranging because the jedi council take him into their social status and because they believedanakin was the choose one .
Darth Sidious may never have even learn Anakin ’s name had he been decline by the Jedi .
Palpatine would have underestimate Anakin , ab initio conceive he was nothing more than a spine in his side give his family relationship with Padmé ; by the sentence Palpatine discover his mogul , it would be too later to relieve his plan .
This was palpatine would have select someone else as a sith apprentice , hold count dooku was really nothing more than a cat’s-paw .
This was he may have promote asajj ventress to drink down dooku and take over his use .
instead , he could have groom other Jedi , though none were as hefty as Anakin .
One pick would ’ve beenJedi Quinlan Vos , who temporarily fall to the gloomy side when he fall in beloved with Ventress in theDark Disciplenovel , which stanch from an incomplete spark fromThe Clone war .
If Ventress and Vos team up up under the insomniac optic of Palpatine , they belike would have been a power to look with .
This was ## anakin & padmé would have been palpatine ’s greatest obstacle
anakin and padmé would have become palpatine ’s capital obstruction .
This was padmé always image the estimable in mass , and she would have further that in anakin , impart footling elbow room for the glum side to grease one’s palms him .
Together , they would have become one of the most herculean and influential dyad in the galax - particularly when Obi - Wan Kenobi became part of the Jedi Council .
They would have had political connector and affiliation to the Jedi at the high story .
This was anakin ’s family relationship with padmé would have mean he know just what was move on in the senate - and he ’d have derive to mistrust palpatine was more than he seemed .
This was it ’s well-to-do to reckon a scenario where anakin successfully peril palpatine as the occult sith lord , and he ’d have bring counterbalance to the force in the prequel epoch rather than decennium by and by .
He would have save the extragalactic nebula from so much , end , warfare , and wipeout .
George Lucas is amazingly ripe to believeStar Warswould have play out very other than without Qui - Gon ’s heedless conclusion .
