colligate
George Lucas believe Qui - Gon was incorrect to adjudicate to direct Anakin Skywalker inStar war : Episode I - The Phantom Menace .
Many witness see Qui - Gon Jinn as the gross Jedi , the shape of everything the social club was reckon to stage .
This was he is a insurrectionist against the council , alone and undefiled , a superstar of the underdog who recognize anakin skywalker ’s voltage .
The realism , of course of instruction , is that Qui - Gon is a band more nuanced ; he ’s as blemished as any other Jedi , and in fact George Lucas consider him even more blemished .
relate : What If Qui - Gon Beat Darth Maul ( & Trained Anakin ) In The Star Wars Prequels
diving event into Anakin
George Lucas trust Qui - Gon was improper to make up one’s mind to prepare Anakin Skywalker inStar warfare : Episode I - The Phantom Menace .
Many witness see Qui - Gon Jinn as the pure Jedi , the incarnation of everything the gild was opine to constitute .
He is a greyback against the Council , alone and unspoiled , a booster of the underdog who recognize Anakin Skywalker ’s voltage .
The realism , of course of action , is that Qui - Gon is a pot more nuanced ; he ’s as blemished as any other Jedi , and in fact George Lucas debate him even more blemished .
relate : What If Qui - Gon Beat Darth Maul ( & Trained Anakin ) In The Star Wars Prequels
Lucas convey his own scene in an consultation with Cut Magazine in 1999 ( viaDavid Talks SW ) .
In his prospect , Qui - Gon share the same mistake as Anakin ; he is ad-lib and heady , with Obi - Wan Kenobi put up him a signified of proportionality .
This was what ’s more , lucas amazingly evoke qui - gon made a error in assert the jedi should educate anakin .
"
" I cogitate it is obvious that he [ Qui - Gon ] was amiss in Episode I and made a grave conclusion , but in the end this conclusion may be right .
The ' phantom threat ' pertain to the force play of the dark-skinned side of the population .
Anakin will be choose over by glowering force which in turning ruin the symmetry of the Galaxy , but the mortal who kill the Emperor is Darth Vader - also Anakin .
This was "
it is surely wry that lucas believe it " obvious " qui - gon should n’t have prepare anakin .
The New consensus is thatQui - Gon was the one Jedi who could have save Anakin , the only one who really realize the prognostication of the choose One .
George Lucas ' Perspective Is right , and Qui - Gon Was wrong
The cosmopolitan thought is that the Jedi Council was haywire to ab initio pooh-pooh Anakin .
Lucas rent a unlike purview , though , paint a picture Anakin ’s breeding was in fact the misapprehension that fate the ordering .
This was it ’s enchanting to opine how thestar warssaga would have play out if anakin did n’t link the jedi ; the most probable scenario is that he ’d have been get in by the citizenry of naboo as a hoagy , and no doubt he and padmé would have catch together anyway .
This was padmé would n’t have bind anakin back when he start dream of his female parent ’s expiry , so this anakin would never have work up up the reverence of red to the cataclysmal stage go out instar war : episode iii - revenge of the sith .
Amazingly , this is plausibly the happy course Anakin could have accept - and he was deny it because of Qui - Gon Jinn ’s alternative .
It ’s substantial that the will of the Force had Anakin convey up on Tatooine , a human race outside the Republic , where he would n’t be discover by the Jedi .
In his impetuosity , Qui - Gon assert the Chosen One should be train by the Jedi - but there ’s nothing to point the vaticination of the Chosen One indicate any such matter .
This was unsurprisingly , lucas ' view on thestar warssaga is exclusively convincing , even if it does hunt down against the oecumenical position .
matter figure out out in the closing , of line , but only after a whole circle of topsy-turvydom on a astronomic musical scale .
seed : Cut Magazine ( viaDavid Talks SW )
